Recreation The Rate My Sig thread!

I made one in BUS, but I'll add a bit of rules for this one to make it more organised, hopefuly it works out well.

The rules are simple, I start with this post, and my current sig, and the next person simply rates it, from a scale of one to ten, gives pointers, whatever.

If you didn't make the signature, please give some credit to the creator.

Also, you can't rate the same person twice in one month, that way we don't fill up with posts, but since this place isn't that active, it should work out fine.

Also, when rating a sig, count the image, the text, links, and whatever.

Starting off with my current one, I did this one in Photoshop, and I've been ripping the Mini Skirt joke for a while now, and I shall never stop

-Seishin

 

10
Very cute and funny. And the Mini Skirt joke is classic.

 

Do we then rate Iya's signature???

If so 11... I love it.

 

From what I gather.

InuyashaROCKS sig is very nice. I always liked Kag and Inu. It is nice to see them in a more natural state then kissing.

I would have to agree that life is full of love and laughs. Very postive attitude.

I also like it when people thank the creator.

Score 9.

 

Well if I have to rate bashers sig, i would rate it a big 10!!!

I really like, nice and dark!!!

 

Hmmm...Soitsu's sig...I give it a 8/10.

oooo, I love these threads, it's nice to find out what people think about your siggy. =)

Btw, this sig o' mine...I made it myself, with a beautiful piece of fanart (who sadly, I do not know the artist of) on MS paint. XD Uh...w00t. XD
It's preobably my favorite RoyxEd pic....with exception to one really HAWT one, that was too big to resize perfectly on paint.....*drools*

 

Oops sorry I uploaded the same one, heres my new sig...sorry...:sweat2:

 

I'm gonna stick to rating both since I don't wanna feel like a spammer

Fushigi Rockna;8/10

Good quality in the picture, great text. Could be transparent, so it would look cooler. Plus,, Yaoi creeps th crap out of me ^^;

Soitsu;3/10

Being honest here.

The quality for the picture is bad, try saving the actual pic on PNG.

The text is horrible, I should know since I used to do the excact same thing, that's paint stuff

Points since it's FMA, but that's a simple picture sized down, that lost quality, and got some bad font added into it.

I'm so evil at rating things

Oddly enough I haven't gotten hate mail from Final Fantasy VII fans for this

I'm so damn strict, and I know all this from experience of what it's like having a crappy sig sometimes, and having great sigs *cough*Zanza*cough*

-Seishin

 

Hey you have to admit it is better than my older ones....well to me it is...

and you'rs umm......MAN I FREAKIN LOVE IT 10/10, if I put anything lower, i'd be ficken stupid!!!!

 

Mmmm......4/10.
Same reasons as Seishin but I like the cats on Al.

 

Iya like a very good sig man the colors are crazy good! like a 9/10

 

I love my One Piece, so I'll give it an 8 out of 10. I like that picture, but the text isn't very stand-out-ish.

 

9/10 it's not the best, but hell it's nicer than most.

 

Creepy. about an 8/10 needs words. I like my sigs with words.

 

Basher gets the ful whack of 10 xD
Believe me and die

it appeears i am late, to post.

 

i got a new sig what do you guys think?

 

w00tness on luffy ^.^

 

All text and no pretty picture to stare at? 7 out of 10 in my book.

 

I dont know... ill give it a 6... just doesnt give out much... feeling

 

Since Seishin made it..automatic greatness. 6/10